We may earn commissions for purchases made through our links (no added cost for you). Every product mentioned in this website is independently selected by Bow Advisor.

The 13 Best Spinning Reels Reviewed & Tested

10. Best Spinning Reel for Crankbaits: PENN BTLII6000 Battle II

If you are heading out to fish crankbaits all afternoon, you’ll want a high-speed reel to make sure you can get your lures down to the target depth quickly and easily. The PENN BTLII6000 Battle II allows you to do exactly that, thanks to its 5.6: 1 gear ratio and impressive 41-inch per crank line retrieval rate.

This reel also provides a lot of line capacity, and it’ll hold up to 490 yards of 30-pound-test braided line.

11. Best Spinning Reel for Trout: Abu Garcia Revo 2SX10

If you want to catch trout with a spinning rig, you’ll need an ultralight model to make it easier to use very lightweight lines and cast tiny lures. The Abu Garcia Revo 2SX10 is a perfect option for anglers chasing trout in shallow rivers and streams.

The Revo 2SX10 is built to the same standards as most other Abu Garcia reels, and it features a ton of high-end options, including a 9-bearing system, carbon matrix hybrid drag and X-Craftic gearbox.

12. Best Spinning Reel for Salmon: Shimano Exsence Spinning Reel

You can’t just catch big salmon with any old reel; you need one that will work smoothly enough to allow you to detect subtle bites while drift fishing, yet still provide enough power and rigidity to handle the heavyweight hooksets you’ll need to use to catch these fish.

Fortunately, the Exsence Spinning Reel includes all of the features salmon anglers need, including a Hagane Body, 12-bearing system and Shimano’s signature MGL Rotor.

13. Best Baitfeeder Spinning Reel: Shimano Baitrunner D Spinning Reel

It takes a bit of finesse and skill to be able to use live bait to consistently catch fish, but the dual drag system included with baitfeeder-style reel will make it much easier to do so.

But unlike cheap dual-drag systems included with many low-cost reels, the Shimano Baitrunner D features a very high-quality dual-drag system, which will make it easy to let big fish swim off with the bait, until you’re ready to engage the primary drag and set the hook.

The Baitrunner D Spinning Reel also allows you to get hooked fish back to the boat quickly, thanks to its 36-inch per crank retrieval rate.

Reviewed Spinning Reels:

Spinning Reel Considerations: What Do You Look for and Why?

Whenever you are picking out a spinning reel, you want to make sure you choose a unit that has the features and characteristics you need to fish successfully. Some of the most important considerations include:

External Parts 

Open face reels are simple devices and most consist of only eight basic external parts and a number of internal components that allow it to function.

Spool

The spool holds the fishing line. The spool of spinning reels is fixed and does not rotate when the line is collected. However, it does turn backward when line tension exceeds the drag setting, allowing the line to unwind.

It also moves up and down as the handle is turned to ensure the line is wrapped evenly around it.

While the spool is a straightforward component, it can have a significant impact on the function of the reel – particularly as it relates to casting. Generally speaking, the easier the line comes off the spool, the farther you are be able to cast.

Some manufacturers alter the profile of their spools to help accomplish this. For example, many spools designed to maximize casting distance are longer, yet shallower which makes it easy for the line to pour off the spool.

Most spools are made from either aluminum or graphite. Opt for the former if you value durability but the latter if you are trying to keep the reel’s weight as low as possible.

If you like to use braided lines, go with a reel that has a braid-ready spool so that you can tie your line directly to the spool.

Reel Body

The reel body serves as the base and it is the part to which most of the other reel components attach. It must fit your hand and fishing style comfortably, but it must also serve as a stable base for the rest of the reel.

Like spools, most reel bodies are made from either aluminum or graphite. Once again, aluminum reel bodies are better for those interested in durability while graphite reel bodies are better for those who want the lightest gear possible.

However, some manufactures drill out holes within aluminum reel bodies to help reduce the weight. Just be sure that these cut-outs do not cause the reel body to flex – you want the body to be as sturdy as an anvil.

Reel Foot

The reel foot is the anchor which keeps the reel attached to the rod. Typically, the foot forms a flanged base which fits into a slot on the rod. The rod handle is then screwed tight which locks the reel into place.

Since most reel feet are simply extensions of the reel body, they are made from the same material.

You don’t have to worry very much about the reel foot when selecting a reel but it should be durable, fits well into the reel seat and holds the reel securely. Fortunately, most modern reels meet these criteria.

Reel Handle

The handle enables the angler to collect fishing line or reel in fish. Most handles are made from either graphite, aluminum or plastic, and they consist of an angled arm and a small, spinning grip.

Different manufacturers use different grip designs but there aren’t any “right” or “wrong” choices here – just be sure to pick a grip style that feels good in your hand.

Reel handles also differ in size. Some feature bigger, beefier grips and arms while others are smaller and lighter.

You should always keep weight in mind, it is usually preferable to select larger handles when possible as these can handle the stresses of fishing better and they are easier to grip quickly when need be.

Bail

The bail is a bent wire arm and metal or plastic frame which encircles the spool. It can be moved into either the “open” or “closed” position.

When open, the line can flow freely from the spool; when closed, the line can be retrieved by turning the reel handle which causes the bail to spin around the spool, wrapping the line around it as it progresses.

Most bails are relatively similar, given their simple design and function. Generally, you only want the bail to be strong with a smooth, polished surface.

Some reels feature an easy-close bail function which is highly desirable as it makes it easier to manually close the bail after casting (cranking the handle to close the bail can damage your reel over time).

Note that a few reel manufacturers produce bail-less designs which are most common on reels intended for fishing from the surf. They work by routing the line directly to the roller, rather than relying on the bail to do so.

Power Roller

Also called the line roller, this small, smooth cylinder serves as a guide for the line while the bail is closed. Rollers are made from a variety of materials, ranging from graphite to aluminum to brass to gold.

Most high-end rollers feature an internal bearing which allows the roller to spin. Rollers made of metal are better suited for braided lines which may cut into rollers made of softer materials.

No matter what materials and construction techniques used to produce a roller, the most important thing is that it spins smoothly and easily, instead of sticking at various points.

This is not a problem when purchasing intermediate- or high-end reels, as these usually feature rollers that offer problem-free performance.

Drag Adjustment

The drag adjustment is a circular dial used to control the amount of force required to strip line from the reel while the bail is closed.

The tension should typically be adjusted so that the line is pulled from the reel with slightly less force than is required to break the line – this prevents the line from snapping during battles with big fish.

Note that drag adjustment dials can be located on the front or back of the reel. Though drag adjustment dials located on the back are easier to adjust while battling fish, front drag adjustment knobs are preferable.

They feature fewer parts than rear drag systems do, and they are also easier to disassemble and maintain. Many anglers feel that front drag systems offer smoother performance and more precise control over the drag than rear ones do.

You may not even have to worry about the differences between front and rear drag systems, as most high-end reels are only available in front-drag configurations.

Anti-Reverse Switch

The anti-reverse switch, when engaged, prevents the reel handle and bail from spinning backward. This helps ensure your hook-sets are rock solid and allows the drag system to feed line to the fighting fish.

When the anti-reverse switch is turned to the off position, the reel handle can be cranked in either direction. This gives the angler the option of reverse reeling when a fish takes off, rather than relying on the drag system.

Some anglers simply prefer to reverse reel rather than depend on the drag. Many fishers used to do so because the drag systems on older reels didn’t always work very well.

Most modern reels, particularly high-end models, feature very smooth drag systems which work better than reverse reeling for battling big fish. In fact, many of the better reels available on the market no longer feature anti-reverse switches.

Internal Parts

Internally, spinning reels contain a variety of gears, bearings, and connectors that make the magic happen. Because spinning reel designs often differ significantly, it is hard to make apples-to-apples comparisons of its internal components.

However, there are a few important aspects that demand your attention:

      • gear ratio
      • number of bearings
      • type of bearings

Gear Ratio

Usually expressed as a numerical ratio (such as 4:1 or 5:1), gear ratio refers to the number of times the bail arm spins for each turn of the handle.

Higher ratios allow you to retrieve line more quickly but lower gear ratios provide more torque as you crank the handle. Typically, reels in the 4:1 range is considered “slow” while those in the 6:1 range are considered “fast.”

Bearings

Shimano Stradic Spinning Reel Bearing

Bearings are another important consideration and they can significantly influence the function of a reel. They are rotating metal or ceramic rings with metal or ceramic balls inside to help reduce friction as the bail arm turns.

When comparing reels with same bearings, the one with more bearings can produce smoother action while a reel with higher-quality bearings almost always outperform a reel with more but lower quality bearings.

Most modern reels (particularly entry-level and intermediate models) feature steel bearings but some of the high-end reels available now use ceramic bearings which provide even smoother operation and are better protected from saltwater and debris.

Shimano and Daiwa both make their versions of these ceramic bearings, calling them ARB bearings and CRBB bearings respectively.

Weight

If you have arms of steel, you don’t have to worry much about the weight of the reel. But most mortals appreciate using a reel that doesn’t tire their arm quickly and allows them to fish all day long.

Reels come in different sizes to suit various fishing situations and target species. Accordingly, this is usually the single most influential factor in a reel’s weight. However, within any given size, class, reel weights can vary quite a bit.

Body Material and Construction

The materials and construction techniques used to produce a spinning reel must be both strong enough to stand up to big fish, as well as light enough to prevent angler fatigue.

Manufacturers do this in a variety of ways, including the use of space-age alloys that are both strong yet light and by removing portions of metal to help reduce the weight.

Modern reels can be made of:

      • plastic
      • graphite
      • copolymer
      • metal

Plastic is only appropriate for young anglers and budget-limited anglers who are pursuing small, freshwater fish such as bluegill and river trout.

Graphite and copolymer are more resilient and work in most freshwater and light saltwater fishing applications. However, metal construction is the preferred choice for serious anglers for fishing both fresh and saltwater.

Note that some reels are made from a few different materials to help reduce weight and costs. However, these types are only as durable as their weakest material so be sure to note the materials used in any reel carefully before making a purchase.

Line Capacity

Large reels can hold more line than smaller ones but, as with weight, there are lots of variation among the models in a given size class. Apparently, the line diameter used also influences a spool’s capacity.

Line capacity printed on spool

For example, a reel may hold 200 yards of 2-pound-test line or 100 yards of 6-pound-test line. In most cases, these line capacities are printed or stamped onto the spool or reel.

You need to determine the line diameter and spool capacity that will work for your target species.

Generally speaking, smaller game fish – bluegill, crappie, perch, and others – will only require light-weight lines and modest line capacities; after all, these fish don’t run very far once hooked.

On the other hand, larger fish – muskies, striped bass, marlins and others – will require heavier lines and generous spool capacities to accommodate the lengthy runs these fish take after snatching a lure.

Drag System

KastKing Mako Spinning Reel drag system
KastKing Mako Spinning Reel drag system

Some reels indicate the amount of drag pressure they can withstand – typically characterized as the “maximum drag pressure”.

Usually, 10 pounds of drag pressure is more than enough to deal with all but the largest bass or trout while larger fish may require a reel capable of standing up to 20 pounds of pressure.

Many reels have ratings that exceed these but in practice, your arms are unlikely to be able to keep up with the 40- or 50-pound ratings some reels boast.

      • High-quality reels feature silky smooth drags which do not vary in their pressure and operate quietly.
      • Low-quality reels typically allow the line to be drawn out in a jerky, stop-and-start fashion.

The former will allow you to catch even the biggest fish all day long without causing you any problems, while the latter will often stop abruptly during battles which often results in a snapped line and lost fish.

Drag quality is often closely tied to overall reel quality, and you’re going to get what you pay for.

Consider How You Fish Too!

In addition to technical details like drag systems and line capacities, you also want to select an open face reel that suits your overall fishing strategy, habits, and desires.

Salt or Fresh Water

You can use just about any spinning reel for freshwater but you need a higher-quality reel designed to resist the corrosive effects of salt water to fish for marine species.

Most saltwater reels accomplish this by using rust-resistant materials and tight-fitting gaskets and seals to keep the saltwater out. Due to the additional features required in their construction, they are usually more expensive than freshwater spinning reels.

We also have an article on how to clean your saltwater spinning reel to maximize its performance and lifespan.

Species

You should identify those species you wish to pursue before selecting a spinning reel as different species attain different sizes and behave differently once hooked.

For example, you want a very lightweight spinning reel designed for 4- to 6-pound-test lines and 1/8- to ¼-ounce lures if you like to pursue panfish and crappie.

On the other hand, anglers pursuing bass or walleye need to use 8- or 10-pound test line so they may want to opt for a heavier weight spinning reel.

You should also consider the line capacity of a spinning reel when picking a model.

      • Anglers fishing for panfish, crappie or rainbow trout won’t need a ton of line capacity as these species rarely engage in lake-crossing runs.
      • You need a reel with a much higher spool capacity if you are targeting large species or those who tend to make several-hundred-yard runs after being hooked.

While spinning reels are made in large enough sizes to work well for just about any freshwater fish you could catch, as well as most moderately sized saltwater species, you may have trouble finding one built to withstand the kind of punishment from large sharks, blue marlin and other saltwater behemoths, who may travel hundreds of yards after biting your lure.

In such cases, you’ll need to look for a conventional (baitcasting) saltwater reel.

Line Preferences

You want to consider the type of line you like to use when selecting a spinning reel. This is primarily a concern for anglers who like to use braided lines as most reels work very well with monofilament and fluorocarbon lines.

Braided lines may cut into the spool of some reels (particularly those made with inferior materials) and they can slip into gaps on some reel designs, causing big problems.

Fortunately, most manufacturers who produce reels that are compatible with braided lines state as much on their product literature and marketing materials. So just review these items carefully before making your selection.

Left-Handed, Right-Handed or Reversible?

Anglers usually prefer reeling with one hand instead of the other, so always be sure to select a reel that has the orientation you prefer. Most right-handed anglers prefer to crank spinning reels with their left hand while left-handed fishers prefer the opposite.

However, there is nothing wrong with pursuing the opposite arrangement. Some reels are designed to work with either hand which can provide additional flexibility.

If you’ve never fished before, it is probably wisest to learn to crank with your left hand as most spinning reels are manufactured for left-handed reeling.

Matching Your Reel to the Rod

It is important to match your reel to your rod carefully to ensure the combo works together seamlessly and provides the kind of performance you want.

This means not only ensuring you match a spinning reel with the right type of rod, but also matching it with a rod that has compatible specifications.

Spinning reels are designed to be used with spinning rods which have a number of features that differ from some other rods. For example, unlike baitcasting or spincasting rods, the line guides of a spinning rod are designed to hang on the rod while in use.

Additionally, spinning rods have larger guides near the reel than these other rod types do as the line pouring off of a spinning reel creates large arcs which would not easily pass through the relatively small guides of these other rod types.

You also need to ensure that your reel and rod are designed for similar line weights.

Most fishing rods have recommended line (and lure) weights printed near the handle. You should use a reel that has a similar recommended line weight to avoid technical problems and poor performance.

Do You Want a Warranty?

Many reels come with a manufacturer’s warranty but you’ll often have the opportunity to purchase an add-on warranty to provide further protection.

Although warranties vary and it is difficult to make sweeping generalizations, it usually makes sense to buy a warranty for any reel that costs you more than $75 or so.

Otherwise, you are better off saving the money you’d spend on the warranty and just put it aside to help fund the purchase a replacement, should this one break.

Ergonomics

A final consideration – an entirely subjective one, at that – is the way the reel feels in your hand.

You’ll simply like the way some reels feel more than others. Unfortunately, it is impossible to determine the way a reel feels when shopping online but you can consult reviews of previous customers to glean a bit of insight on the feel of the reel.

Leading Spinning Reel Brands

There are some dominant brands in the spinning reel category. While there are smaller manufacturers who produce a few models, those big brands produce the bulk of your choices.

Each major brand tends to have different strengths and weaknesses and brand-wide tendencies with which you may want to familiarize yourself.

Shimano

Shimano is a huge company, headquartered in Japan, which produces a broad range of products including bicycles, rowing equipment, golf supplies and fishing reels.

With a lineup that includes 19 different reel series, they try to produce reels to suit just about any angler’s needs — whether you fish saltwater or freshwater, or you target tiny fish or giants.

This includes reels designed to work well for beginning anglers as well as some of the most impressive (and expensive) reels on the market such as the Stella line referenced above.

It is hard to characterize Shimano’s reel collection, thanks in part to the sheer number of different reels they produce, but most anglers find that they produce a reel that includes the features they seek.

Some of the features that are common to most Shimano reels include the G-Free Body reel design which moves the reel’s center of gravity closer to your hand, thereby making it easier to use for extended periods of time without fatiguing.

Several Shimano reels also feature the X-Protect system which is comprised of a waterproof coating and a water-channeling design. Both features combine to help protect the internal reel mechanisms from salt water and sand.

Penn

Penn spinning reel

Penn is an American reel and rod manufacturer who produces different spinning reels ranging from entry-level to their top-of-the-line Torque II series which is one of the toughest reels on the market.

Primarily designed for saltwater anglers, Penn packs their reels with most of the features you’d want in a fishing reel including their patented Dura-Drag system which provides one of the best drag functions among all reels.

Many of their reels also come with line capacity rings printed on the spool. These rings allow you to determine how much line is on your spool at a glance.

Penn’s Slammer series is another great option from Penn’s product line. A formerly discontinued line, these were brought back to quench incredible customer demand.

These reels – like several other in Penn’s product lineup – feature the IPX6 sealed body and spool design which makes them well-suited for saltwater anglers.

And for those who are looking for even more salt-water protection, the Spinfisher line features a water-tight design to prevent corrosion.

Abu Garcia

Abu Garcia is a well-known and beloved brand among most modern anglers. Originally founded in Sweden in 1921, this company (which is now headquartered in the USA) has introduced some significant innovations to the spinning reel market.

For example, several of their modern reel designs feature the Rocket Line Management System and the Rocket Spool Lip Design which combine to provide improved casting distance and line control.

Their trademarked Carbon Matrix Drag System is also widely praised by anglers, thanks to its smooth operation and dependability.

While most of Abu Garcia’s reels are designed for the mid- or high-level angler, they also offer a budget line. Apparently, their budget reels do not possess a number of the high-end features that their higher-quality reels do.

But it gives cash-strapped buyers a chance to fish with an Abu Garcia reel without spending a ton of money.

Abu Garcia makes reels for both fresh and saltwater fishing. Most of their models come in several sizes so you can match your reel to the species you like to catch.

Daiwa

Daiwa has been making fishing equipment, including spinning reels, since 1955. Now headquartered in Cypress, California, the company produces several high-quality reels for intermediate and advanced anglers and a series that is suited for a beginning angler.

Several Daiwa reels feature the Twist Buster TM roller system which helps reduce line twist and some are made from a high-density carbon material which is both lighter and stronger than the carbon that other manufacturers use in their reels.

Daiwa’s top-of-the-line offering is the Certate series. Featuring aluminum construction, Digigear gears and components and nine bearings to guarantee smooth operation, the Cerate Series is excellent for battling big fish.

Even their budget-priced line includes some high-end features such as a waterproof Carbon ATD drag system, an aluminum handle, and a braid-ready spool.

Share Your Thoughts

Do you have a spinning reel brand or model that you love to use? What about a brand or model that failed to hold up the way you wanted? We’d love to hear about your experiences and recommendations in the comments below.

If you are also looking for a rod to pair it with your new reel take a look at our fishing rod buyer guide.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

Bow Advisor ©️ Copyright Bow Advisor (bowadvisor.com) is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.